Skip to main content
Rank 2
November 5, 2024
Solved

Tariff switch timing wrong? Eco 10 new meter

  • November 5, 2024
  • 19 replies
  • 831 views

Hi all! 
I’m a conscript grime SSE. I have Eco10 with a Landis and Gyr meter. I have storage heating.

the heating is added in to the normal circuit by a contractor fitted at the same time as the smart meter.

The economy rate is switching in and out either early or late depending on how it feels. 

I could only tell it was switching in or out by the clonk. There is no indicator of which rate is active. I’ve now got a bulb to indicate on economy. 
I’ve now got a timer on economy so I can see active economy hours.

I'm only actually getting 9 hours of economy rate instead of 10. 

Not a good start. 
I ignored the sudden £5000 debt for now.

I know a lot of you are volunteers so I appreciate your help. 🙈
 

Best answer by Firedog

Updated on 06/05/25 by Abby_OVO

 

The pictures are very helpful, thanks.

We’ve seen this sort of meter before, but with a Landis + Gyr contactor for the offpeak circuits bolted on to the meter itself, like this:
  

L+G E470 5533 with L470 5451 100A contactor 


You have a separate one which ought to behave in the same way. The meter sends a signal at the appropriate time (down the thin blue cable) to the contactor to switch the power on and off to your heating equipment. 

It sounds a bit unlikely that the switching time varies from day to day; the times should be set in stone inside the meter itself. If you can document the times the circuit switches on and off (the two daytime slots would probably do), you’d have some evidence for the smart team to examine. 

The switching times should coincide with the tariff changes to avoid not intentionally powering up heaters outside of offpeak hours. There may be a built-in delay to make sure you’re on the cheap rate before the heating switches on; with six switching times, this could add up to perhaps half an hour. If the times are very different, something’s not right. Get your facts together - along with the photos - and then get in touch with Support.

You can always run other equipment at the cheaper rate - washer, dryer, hoover, for example - from the start of an offpeak period regardless of when the heating is turned on.

 

For more information on Economy 10, check out the topic below:

 

19 replies

Blastoise186
Super User
Super User
November 5, 2024

Good evening @Mclacr ,

Thanks for bringing this up. We just need one more thing to help us answer this one, if you’re up for it. Please post photos of your setup so we can see exactly what you’ve got. If you’d rather not, let us know and we’ll work with what we’ve got here.

Thanks!

Securing energy by zapping security bugs... For that is The Blastoise Way! Remember, I'm just like you - AI Powered Evil Geniuses aren't Staff!
MclacrAuthor
Rank 2
November 5, 2024

Thanks, I hope this helps. I’ll have a go at a wiring diagram if needed. 

Firedog
Super User
FiredogSuper UserSolved
Super User
November 6, 2024

Updated on 06/05/25 by Abby_OVO

 

The pictures are very helpful, thanks.

We’ve seen this sort of meter before, but with a Landis + Gyr contactor for the offpeak circuits bolted on to the meter itself, like this:
  

L+G E470 5533 with L470 5451 100A contactor 


You have a separate one which ought to behave in the same way. The meter sends a signal at the appropriate time (down the thin blue cable) to the contactor to switch the power on and off to your heating equipment. 

It sounds a bit unlikely that the switching time varies from day to day; the times should be set in stone inside the meter itself. If you can document the times the circuit switches on and off (the two daytime slots would probably do), you’d have some evidence for the smart team to examine. 

The switching times should coincide with the tariff changes to avoid not intentionally powering up heaters outside of offpeak hours. There may be a built-in delay to make sure you’re on the cheap rate before the heating switches on; with six switching times, this could add up to perhaps half an hour. If the times are very different, something’s not right. Get your facts together - along with the photos - and then get in touch with Support.

You can always run other equipment at the cheaper rate - washer, dryer, hoover, for example - from the start of an offpeak period regardless of when the heating is turned on.

 

For more information on Economy 10, check out the topic below:

 

Noel | I have no official status; I'm just a volunteer who comes here to help other customers. My gear: Aclara SGM 1416-B Electricity-only E7 meter; Chameleon IHD3-PPMID-AAA | It may look as if I know what I’m talking about, but don’t let that fool you. |
MclacrAuthor
Rank 2
November 6, 2024

Thanks @Firedog it has been hard to catch the times but I can try harder. I’ve got alarms set for the published times and I can set up a lamp where I am in the house so I can log when off peak switches. At the moment I know I’m an hour short each day on off peak. 
thanks for the tech help. It’s helpful to have how I thought it should work confirmed. I’ll do some logging and get on to support and report back.

Abby_OVO
Community Manager
Community Manager
November 6, 2024

Hey @Mclacr 

 

I’m really glad to see a couple of our volunteers have already stopped by with some really helpful advice already.

 

Firedog has given you a nice little timeline to follow of getting your information together along with photos, so if you do a closer check and take all your info to the Support Team they’ll be able to help out better, they’d ask you to do all of this anyway so it’s a good thing Firedog has already let you know to do this.

 

Let us know how you get on with everything

Currently Playing: She's Electric
MclacrAuthor
Rank 2
November 6, 2024

Thanks @Abby-OVO

MclacrAuthor
Rank 2
November 11, 2024
Tariff switching chart. Tafiff V Actual

Just to update  @Abby_OVO @Blastoise186  @Blastoise186  I’ve just emailed support.

Firedog
Super User
Super User
November 11, 2024

Interesting, @Mclacr , thanks for getting up so early to check!

My guess - without having any evidence or experience to back it up - is that the 8 minute delay in switch-off time is the one built-in to the meter, the so-called randomized offset. This is part of SMETS2, designed to prevent unacceptable surges in demand when large numbers of power-hungry appliances are switched simultaneously. It should apply equally to tariff- and load-switching times.

The half-hour delay in switch-on times might be introduced either by the ALCS or by the heaters themselves to prevent them using electricity at peak rates before the tariff changes. 30 minutes is the maximum randomized offset, so switching on half an hour after the advertised time should avoid that particular problem. 

If the 30 minute delay is thanks to the ALCS, I don’t know whether it’s possible to tweak it to times like, say, 00:10-05:10, 13:10-16:10 and 20:10-22:10. The smart team will know. That way, you’d get almost the full whack of offpeak hours if that’s important.

One last question: you haven’t mentioned where you are in the world - which DNO region. I would have guessed from your username N Scotland (Scottish Hydro, the region known as 17 or P). We’re told that the E10 switching times are quite different from the ones you’re seeing, so perhaps you’re in the Southern England region (SEB, 20, H). The times you see match what they’re supposed to be down there. 

The region number is the first two digits of the bottom line of your MPAN (not the MSN you see on the meter - that starts with the year of manufacture).  

 

Noel | I have no official status; I'm just a volunteer who comes here to help other customers. My gear: Aclara SGM 1416-B Electricity-only E7 meter; Chameleon IHD3-PPMID-AAA | It may look as if I know what I’m talking about, but don’t let that fool you. |
MclacrAuthor
Rank 2
November 11, 2024

@Firedog  Thanks, I’m in the South of England. I was given the timings by OVO on the phone, they are the same as I can find by research. Also I’m not getting the duration of off peak power that I was told I would. The heaters are dumb, just a thermostat. 
I was told that the off peak period was for everything. I would have chosen a different tariff if that wasn’t the case. I understand load shifting. 
I got an awful reply from support. I’ll post it below.

cheers, Rob
 

MclacrAuthor
Rank 2
November 11, 2024

I'm writing this email following your recent query.

As you have had the Smart Meter installed on the 28th of October it can take a few weeks for the selected times to be correlated with the system however please be assured that this will resolve itself and you will have the selected times on the meter as requested.

Please accept my apologies for any inconvenience caused.

Kind Regards