Geo Trio II IHD – Three Devices Failed to Connect, Home Mini Works (Octopus SMETS2)
Geo Trio II IHD – Three Devices Failed to Connect, Home Mini Works (Octopus SMETS2)
I'm sharing my experience with a persistent Geo Trio II In-Home Display (IHD) connection problem, in case it helps others experiencing similar issues.
After approximately six weeks of troubleshooting with Octopus Energy, followed by a formal complaint, the issue remains unresolved. Octopus has now closed the complaint by agreement, providing an Octopus Home Mini as an alternative and a £50 goodwill credit.
I'm an engineer myself, so I'm particularly interested in understanding what might have caused the problem.
1. My smart-meter installation
Our installation consists of:
-
Electricity meter: Kaifa MA120 (SMETS2)
-
Communications hub: Toshiba 4G DBCH
-
Gas meter: SMETS2 smart gas meter
-
In-Home Display: Geo Trio II
-
Energy supplier: Octopus Energy
-
Additional device: Octopus Home Mini (installed later)
The Toshiba communications hub is mounted above the electricity meter and has five status indicators: SW, WAN, PWR, HAN and GAS.
The installation worked correctly for approximately four months, with the Geo IHD displaying both electricity and gas consumption.
Then, without any changes to the equipment or its location, the IHD suddenly stopped receiving data from both meters.
2. Error messages
The Geo IHD displayed the following errors:
23-1 – Meter Network Problem
28-2 – Electricity Meter Service Issue
29-2 – Gas Meter Service Issue
The display also showed a crossed-out network signal indicator.
Interestingly, the IHD itself continued to function normally in terms of its menus and settings. It simply could not obtain consumption data.
3. What we established
During the investigation, Octopus confirmed that it could communicate remotely with both the electricity and gas meters.
This suggested that the meters and their external communications were functioning.
The Toshiba communications hub's status LEDs were flashing green, and there was no alarm indication on the Kaifa electricity meter.
I also tried resetting the IHD's user data and positioning it immediately next to the communications hub.
Neither made any difference.
4. Troubleshooting with Octopus
Over approximately six weeks, I had numerous email exchanges and telephone conversations with Octopus's customer service team.
I should emphasise that the customer service representatives were consistently helpful and genuinely tried to resolve the issue.
However, progress with the back-office technical team was disappointing.
The troubleshooting included:
-
Checking remote communication with the electricity and gas meters.
-
Resetting the Geo IHD's user data.
-
Moving the IHD close to the Toshiba communications hub.
-
Supplying the IHD serial number and EUI/barcode information.
-
Multiple attempts by Octopus to recommission the IHD.
-
Waiting for the recommended commissioning periods.
-
Trying replacement Geo IHD devices.
In total, three Geo IHDs were tried, and none could establish a working connection.
Despite these attempts, the same problem persisted.
5. The interesting development: Octopus Home Mini works!
Octopus subsequently supplied an Octopus Home Mini as an alternative way to monitor our energy consumption.
I installed it myself through the Octopus app.
It connected successfully and now provides live electricity consumption information without any problems.
This was a significant development.
The Home Mini communicates with the smart-meter system through the local Zigbee Home Area Network (HAN), while also using our home Wi-Fi to communicate with the Octopus app.
Its successful operation demonstrates that the local HAN can communicate with at least one authorised consumer device.
Therefore, a complete failure of the Toshiba hub's Zigbee radio seems unlikely.
However, the Geo IHD still cannot connect.
6. My technical observations
As an engineer, I find this particularly interesting.
We now have the following situation:
| Component | Status |
|---|---|
| Kaifa electricity meter | Remote readings working |
| Gas smart meter | Remote readings working |
| Toshiba communications hub | Remote communications working |
| Octopus Home Mini | Connected and providing live electricity data |
| Geo IHD No. 1 | Failed to connect |
| Geo IHD No. 2 | Failed to connect |
| Geo IHD No. 3 | Failed to connect |
My suspicion is that the problem may be related to the software configuration or commissioning of Geo IHD devices on the HAN, rather than a general communications failure.
Possible explanations include:
-
Incorrect or incomplete IHD commissioning.
-
An issue with the HAN device whitelist or device records.
-
A problem establishing the IHD's electricity and gas service associations.
-
An issue with the communications hub's handling of IHD connections.
-
A compatibility or firmware problem affecting the Geo devices.
These are hypotheses, not confirmed diagnoses.
I suggested that Octopus investigate the IHD-specific commissioning process and whether obsolete device records or associations could be causing the problem.
I also wondered whether restarting the Toshiba communications hub might clear a persistent software problem.
However, Octopus did not pursue a hub reset or an engineer visit specifically to investigate the IHD.
7. Octopus's final response
Following my formal complaint, Octopus consulted its Smart Metering team and management.
They confirmed that they had exhausted the troubleshooting options available to them.
They also stated that they had not approached the Geo manufacturer because they were not aware of other reported or widespread problems with these devices.
Their diagnostics continued to indicate that the IHD was either unplugged or outside the required range of the electricity meter.
This was clearly inconsistent with the physical situation, as the IHD was powered on and positioned immediately next to the meter.
Octopus ultimately concluded that they could not get the Geo IHD working and would not arrange an engineer visit specifically for this issue.
They offered the Home Mini as a practical alternative and £50 goodwill credit in recognition of the inconvenience and time spent troubleshooting.
I accepted this resolution, and the formal complaint has now been closed.
Although I am disappointed that the underlying technical fault remains unexplained, I appreciate the efforts of the customer service team and the alternative solution provided.
8. What happens next?
I have decided to keep the latest Geo IHD powered on and positioned next to the electricity meter and Toshiba communications hub.
I'm curious whether it might eventually reconnect, perhaps following a power interruption or a restart of the relevant communications equipment.
That is only a hypothesis, but if it does reconnect, I will report the outcome to Octopus and update this thread.
In the meantime, the Home Mini is working well and provides the live consumption information we originally wanted from the smart-meter installation.
9. Has anyone experienced something similar?
I would be particularly interested to hear from anyone who has experienced:
-
Geo Trio II errors 23-1, 28-2 or 29-2.
-
Multiple Geo IHDs failing to connect to the same SMETS2 installation.
-
Problems specifically involving a Toshiba 4G communications hub.
-
A Home Mini working correctly while a Geo IHD fails.
-
An IHD connection problem that was eventually resolved by a communications hub restart, replacement or changes to HAN commissioning.
Has anyone managed to identify the underlying cause or find a permanent solution?
I hope sharing this experience helps others and perhaps provides useful information for someone investigating similar faults.
I'll update the thread if anything changes.
