Skip to main content
Rank 1
January 10, 2024
Solved

THTC meter - Removal Request

  • January 10, 2024
  • 240 replies
  • 7845 views

Hi folks,

 

I am trying to have a redundant THTC meter removed from my house and OVO seem to be refusing to do this. Can anyone help explain what I should do? Some background info below:

 

We moved to a property in March last year in the west of Scotland. The property has two meters with a THTC setup running storage heaters. We are getting the storage heaters removed in February and an air source heat pump installed. 

 

Once this work has been carried out there will be nothing running from the RadioTelemeter (THTC) meter.

 

I have contacted OVO by phone yesterday to request that this meter be removed once it is no longer in use. The person I spoke with said that OVO would not do this because doing so would stop the other (ordinary) meter working. They weren’t able to explain why this would be the case. After some time on the phone I was told that if I emailed OVO with evidence that the THTC meter would not powering anything then they could arrange for it to be removed. This seemed like a positive outcome although it was not clear why we were initially told in the call that removal wasn’t possible.

 

I sent an email last night attaching the quotes from our electrician and heating engineer for removal of storage heaters and replacement with heat pump etc. I got a positive response this morning:

I am Stephen from account management at OVO energy after reading your email we can go ahead and do that for you but i am going to give you extra information so to proceed with this job there is a charge due to the nature of it I would like to clarify that your okay with that and if you are i can go ahead and get you a price and and book the job for you.

 

Again this seemed positive and I asked Stephen to go ahead and give us a cost. I then had response email from Nahim:

Apologies for the confusion form what Stephan said but as of right now, appointments for removing THTC meters aren't available. We appreciate you gave us confirmation the property's heating system is no longer dependant.

However we are working on a new meter type that'll basically replace the current two meters and you'll get one meter. The meter will reveal at Spring and you'll get an email when your free meter upgrade is ready

 

As far as I understand it the ‘new meter type’ mentioned has been in development for years and has been repeatedly delayed. I have little to no confidence that it will arrive in spring as promised above. It isn’t clear why we should be expected to wait for this.

 

Ontop of that our experience from speaking to neighbours and friends locally is that smart meters are useless in this (rural) area since they are not able to connect to a radio mast for communication. Any smart meters fitted simply operate as ‘dumb’ meters in this area.

 

Can anyone give us some hope that it is possible to get the redundant THTC meter removed as we have requested? Is there any technical reason why this wouldn’t be possible?

 

Failing that at least any good reason why we should have to wait for the new meter to be developed and rolled out? It seems in this instance that whilst waiting we’d have headaches if we wanted to switch supplier etc because we’d have a strange setup with a redundant meter and two MPAN numbers associated with the property. This could go on indefinitely since the new meters are not yet launched.

 

Below is a photograph of our current setup incase this is useful:

 

 

We’d really appreciate any help on this!

 

Thanks

 

 

 

Best answer by Nukecad

They may well ask for consumer feedback later; once those initial proposals have been refined by industry discussions.

However at the moment that isn’t what they want or need.

So it’s best not to clog up their email with unwanted stuff that just takes up their time to deal with.
(There’s a word we all use for unwanted emails - spam).

Wait and see if they do ask for consumer feedback/opinion, but TBH there may not be time.
The clock is counting down and contingency plans need to be in place for when it reaches zero in June.

240 replies

Newcomer
August 12, 2024

I’m sorry to hear this. I’ll get our Forum_Support team to reach out again to look into this further for you.

@Shads_OVO Thanks!

I haven’t heard anything yet from the Forum_Support team.

Also haven’t heard from the Advisor I spoke to last week who promised to email me with an explanation as to why I can’t get a Smart Meter. 

Firedog
Super User
Super User
August 12, 2024

​​ - truth is, I may well be WAN-able.
It’d be helpful to know either way, but from reading previous posts, it seems difficult to get this info?
If anyone has any tips or tricks, I’d be grateful to hear them.

 

The problem is that it’s DCC who rule over the ‘coverage map’ which tells suppliers and installers whether the SM WAN is likely to reach a particular property or not. No mere electricity customer can get to know what it says about his own neck of the woods, and of course it can never be perfectly accurate. 

Arqiva tend to mount SM WAN aerials on the 1500 or so television transmitter masts they have dotted about the kingdom. If you have decent TV reception, your TV aerial is probably pointing towards the mast where your SM WAN antenna is mounted. If your meter box/cupboard happens to be on the opposite side of the house and the house is hewn from native granite, there might well be problems. 

However, there are so many customers in similar situations that some of the more adventurous RF-savvy ones have come up with solutions that seem to work in many cases. You could spend an entertaining hour or two trawling through threads like this one to see how people have overcome the hurdles, started receiving and transmitting smart meter data and promptly switched to suppliers offering favourable EV tariffs. 

And somewhere over the rainbow there’s a scheme to equip awkward customers in the north region with dual-mode meters that default to the LRR solution but switch to a mobile phone band if that doesn’t work. Of course, if your bothy on the banks of the Quoich is out of range of both, this won’t help. But then, not many bothies up there have mains electricity anyway, so it’s probably moot. 

 

Noel | I have no official status; I'm just a volunteer who comes here to help other customers. My gear: Aclara SGM 1416-B Electricity-only E7 meter; Chameleon IHD3-PPMID-AAA | It may look as if I know what I’m talking about, but don’t let that fool you. |
Chris_OVO
Community Manager
Community Manager
August 13, 2024

Hey @monster9,

 

We’ve been updating you on this thread: 

If we could keep the conversations going on one thread that would be amazing, as it holds everything together 😊

Renewable energy jokes never get old.
Newcomer
August 15, 2024

Thanks @Firedog 

I looked at the local planning portal’s historic planning applications and identified that Arqiva do indeed have an antenna close-by, although hidden from sight (neighbours tell me there’s a dish nailed to a tree not 500m from the house).
That planning portal detailed a request from Arqiva to install a VSAT link.
Not sure what that link would be used for - could be any sort of data, I suppose?

We do get the majority of Freeview channels in the house, so that’s also encouraging.

P.S. the house is hewn from native granite.

😐

P.P.S.

The planning portal and your television transmitter masts link both identify the same location.

That transmitter is identified as “Freeview light transmitter”.

Firedog
Super User
Super User
August 15, 2024

I’m sure there’s a reference to ‘Freeview Light’ masts somewhere in those EV forums, where IIRC the poster claimed that they were typically not used to host SMWAN aerials. I may have got that wrong, but you might have a look yourself. So even though you have a decent TV signal, it may be coming from the wrong sort of mast …

And this old pedant should have read what he wrote before posting. It sounded all right, but of course it’s the granite that’s hewn, not the house. But you got my meaning. Anyway, with a house like that, it would be vital to have the meter (or at least any antenna that might be taken into use) is on the windward side of the house, so to speak, i.e. with no bits of house between the meter/antenna and the mast it’s trying to connect to.

 

Noel | I have no official status; I'm just a volunteer who comes here to help other customers. My gear: Aclara SGM 1416-B Electricity-only E7 meter; Chameleon IHD3-PPMID-AAA | It may look as if I know what I’m talking about, but don’t let that fool you. |
Newcomer
August 23, 2024

I’m sure there’s a reference to ‘Freeview Light’ masts somewhere in those EV forums, where IIRC the poster claimed that they were typically not used to host SMWAN aerials.@Firedog 

Just received a call from OVO support telling me there’s no WAN connectivity in my area, therefore, no possibility of a Smart meter.

I asked when the WAN would be provided at my location and was told there is no target date.

Still confused as to how my neighbour has a working Smart meter, if this is the case?

I asked about the possibility of utilising my neighbour’s meter in order to connect to the WAN as I believe this meter-to-meter communication is possible. It sounded like this was news to the advisor.

 

Newcomer
August 30, 2024

Progress!

I’ve been promised a site visit in a week or so to check what is possible at my property.

Fingers crossed!

In a separate note, someone on a forum elsewhere has stated that “"I’ve spoken to a different agent at OVO this morning who has now confirmed that THTC meters are being replaced with a dual circuit smart meter"

Is anyone able to verify this “Dual circuit smart meter” theory, please?

It sounds entirely plausible. My worry would be that trying to move away from OVO with this kind of Smart meter may pose problems for the new supplier?

Blastoise186
Super User
Super User
August 30, 2024

By Dual-Circuit I think they actually meant 5-Terminal. OVO has no plans to do Twin Element Smart Meters.

Securing energy by zapping security bugs... For that is The Blastoise Way! Remember, I'm just like you - AI Powered Evil Geniuses aren't Staff!
Firedog
Super User
Super User
August 30, 2024

Oh dear, the vagaries of technical terms! It would be good if @monster9 could give us the reference to the ‘other forum’ post he read. 

I’d be inclined to think that it was referring to the ‘dual mode’ communication hubs currently being trialled, the ones that have both LRR and ‘mobile’ transceivers in a belt-and-braces approach to communication. I’m furious that I can’t remember where I read about them.

There’s also confusion with ‘dual band’ CHs for the Northern region, probably only in the RAF Fylingdales danger zone. They operate in both the 420 and 450 MHz bands for the WAN, but they also have both 823MHz and 2400MHz HAN capability. I’d call that ‘double-dual-band’!

‘Dual circuit’ does sound like a five-wire arrangement similar to that already being used by many THTC systems - one for heating and hot water, the other for everything else. There’s nothing new about this.

Noel | I have no official status; I'm just a volunteer who comes here to help other customers. My gear: Aclara SGM 1416-B Electricity-only E7 meter; Chameleon IHD3-PPMID-AAA | It may look as if I know what I’m talking about, but don’t let that fool you. |
Shads_OVO
Retired Moderator
Retired Moderator
September 2, 2024

Hi @monster9,

 

Are you able to provide a link to the other topic so we can take a look into this for you?