Skip to main content
Rank 2
January 7, 2025
Solved

I have FIT with new battery and inverter, do I have the right meters?

  • January 7, 2025
  • 79 replies
  • 2855 views

Wondered if anyone can answer my query

 

Im an existing FIT payment receiver (solar panels installed with single string inverter 11 years ago) so receive a decent FIT payment.

 

Recently had installed a EcoFlow 3.6kw inverter with 10kw battery storage, the generation meter was changed to a bidirectional meter as instructed and followed the correct schematic.

 

However the meter is showing a negative number and I can’t seem to work out what the solar panels are generating apart from what shows in the EcoFlow app

 

We charge the batteries up at night using an off peak rate and then any solar during the day tops the batteries up.

 

am I correct in thinking there should be another meter of sort between the solar panels and inverter just to monitor the generation from The solar panels?

 

installers seem to think by summer it will change to a positive but that’s no good to me right now when I’ve generated about 30kw of solar 

 

 

Best answer by BPLightlog

Actually, the NET meter is normally the correct one to use. It calculates the difference between any import from the grid and your generation. During winter and acknowledging losses in the system, if you are significantly charging overnight and then discharging during the day, it can show negative at this time of year. 
You might just double check with your FIT provider as to which reading they will accept. As I mentioned, normally it’s the NET reading but some want the EXP reading. 
There will be no other meter just for generation on a set up like yours (mine is the same)

79 replies

BPLightlog
Super User
Super User
March 19, 2025

Hi everyone,

I have read the thread above but am still confused. We have just had a hybrid inverter fitted together with a battery. This coincided with our diary reminder to submit the FIT reading for the quarter. I had a photo of the old generation meter, but no-one explained the new bi-directional meter. I foolishly believed the Exp figure was the one required but my FIT provider came back and said they wanted the Net figure which was a negative amount. They explained it was negative because we were taking more to charge the battery from the grid than we were exporting. We are on a fixed price tariff and not a cheap overnight tariff so there’s no gain in using the grid to charge the battery and as far as I am aware our system is not set up to do that ( and the Fox App seems to confirm that as the graphic display never shows any grid power going to the battery). It seems we are being penalised twice over. Any power I import from the grid I pay for via my normal Smart Electricity Meter. My panels are producing power which I consume in the house and any surplus goes to the battery for later consumption at night. By sending a Net reading it seems to me I am paying to import power from the grid and at the same time this is negating the power/£p I generate from the panels. I thought the FIT procedure was to pay the householder for all the power generated by the panels (as it did on the old meter). Surely the same applies now whether you use all you generate, or whether you divert excess PV power to the battery? It seems by upgrading we have achieved one step forward but taken two steps backwards and are now out of pocket and ever will be.

If you are not charging from the grid, then you shouldn’t have much reduction in your generation reading. There is a + and - effect when you use surplus solar to charge the batteries but unless there is a huge amount of surplus, it would work out mostly balanced - I say mostly as you never get as much out of the batteries as you put in due to the losses (around 10%).

If you think that the negative effect on your net meter (and therefore generation reading) is significantly higher than it should be, you might want to get the cabling checked out as the grid only part of your supply to the property should not go through the net meter.

Bring me Sunshine ~ E&E {Solar PV, Battery Storage, Hybrid EV, ASHP and Home Assistant automation}
Newcomer
March 19, 2025

Thanks. Another respondent has similarly commented that the cabling might be wrongly connected as my negative net reading is climbing each day in this sunny weather. Have put in an urgent request to the Installer to revisit and check the wiring. Same reader sent me a schematic of the difference between the old generation meter and the bi-directional meter.  Hopefully that diagnosis is the correct one, but then I have the problem of convincing my FIT provider that the negative net reading is actually a positive one!

Newcomer
March 26, 2025

Hi everyone,

After much angst dealing with uncooperative Installer and FIT provider, and tremendous help from Alex, his diagnosis of my problem was correct. The electricians wired the bi-directional meter in the same way as the previous generation meter which is entirely wrong. The wiring is 180 degrees different hence my meter was counting backwards and the net reading was an increasing minus. They’ve been today to fit me a new meter starting at zero and it appears to be counting upwards this time - hooray!

I’ve requested a letter of explanation and apology from the Installers and will use that to try to convince my FIT supplier to credit me with the negative final figure (that should be a positive).

In researching all this I’m having second thoughts about topping up my battery overnight on a cheaper tariff as this will increase my Export meter potentially wiping out my Import figure leaving me with no FIT generation/£p. I can’t do anything until July when my present fixed tariff expires but I am going to have to calculate whether the gain on using cheaper priced fuel downloaded to my battery overnight compensates for the loss in FIT revenue if I end up with a minus NET figure again.

Thanks to everyone who chipped in to help (even OVO - and I’m not even with them) but especially Alex who spent time on the telephone with me going over the possibilities. Your help very much appreciated Alex.

Blastoise186
Super User
Super User
March 26, 2025

Hey, no worries! Glad we could help!

If you need us for basically anything else, feel free to swing by anytime. We’ll be more than happy to see you again. :)

Securing energy by zapping security bugs... For that is The Blastoise Way! Remember, I'm just like you - AI Powered Evil Geniuses aren't Staff!
Abby_OVO
Community Manager
Community Manager
March 27, 2025

Hey ​@David49 

 

Thanks for coming back with that update!

 

I’m glad they were able to get to the bottom of that for you. Do keep us updated on how you get on getting some credit back if they can.

 

As Blastoise mentioned, feel free to pop back anytime.😊

Currently Playing: She's Electric
Newcomer
March 27, 2025

Hi everyone,

After much angst dealing with uncooperative Installer and FIT provider, and tremendous help from Alex, his diagnosis of my problem was correct. The electricians wired the bi-directional meter in the same way as the previous generation meter which is entirely wrong. The wiring is 180 degrees different hence my meter was counting backwards and the net reading was an increasing minus. They’ve been today to fit me a new meter starting at zero and it appears to be counting upwards this time - hooray!

I’ve requested a letter of explanation and apology from the Installers and will use that to try to convince my FIT supplier to credit me with the negative final figure (that should be a positive).

In researching all this I’m having second thoughts about topping up my battery overnight on a cheaper tariff as this will increase my Export meter potentially wiping out my Import figure leaving me with no FIT generation/£p. I can’t do anything until July when my present fixed tariff expires but I am going to have to calculate whether the gain on using cheaper priced fuel downloaded to my battery overnight compensates for the loss in FIT revenue if I end up with a minus NET figure again.

Thanks to everyone who chipped in to help (even OVO - and I’m not even with them) but especially Alex who spent time on the telephone with me going over the possibilities. Your help very much appreciated Alex.

 

No worries David, I could feel your pain in the post and thought it best to speak to discuss our respective journeys! 

 

I have calculated that when all is said and done I am seeing 89% of the yield reported on the inverter. My Sunsynk consumes 1.2kw per day, that’ll always be covered by Solar generation in ANY weather but in my new hybrid setup, that amounts to £300 lost Fit Payments for keeping it on standby

I think in the winter it maybe worth charging but I wouldn’t charge to 100%, maybe 80% I noticed charging to 100% causes more losses. I also used to ‘top up’ the battery when I got cheaper slots of 7p charging open up with Octopus. To be clear, to anyone NOT on an old FIT scheme, top up and charge all you want. You don’t need to have a generation meter I believe, so it really doesn’t matter. But for FIT folks with Hybrid Meter you need to sip grid power

My advice actually would be to keep your existing inverter, if you get batteries, run them with a dedicated AC coupled inverter on a different circuit entirely. So any charging/discharging of the batteries would have NO impact on the generation meter whatsoever. It takes up more space yes, but not that much more. 

Kanulondon (aka Alex)

Newcomer
April 27, 2025

Sorry to keep this thread going.I'm still a bit confused by this. I'm the same as other users ,on old fit payments from solar installed 12 years ago,just had inverter replaced with hybrid and a battery plus new bidirectional meter.On fit I get paid for everything I generate from solar but now your saying if I charge the battery from the grid that gets taken off my solar generated figure..is this correct? But not the rest of my grid use for the house? Thanks in advance.

BPLightlog
Super User
Super User
April 27, 2025

Sorry to keep this thread going.I'm still a bit confused by this. I'm the same as other users ,on old fit payments from solar installed 12 years ago,just had inverter replaced with hybrid and a battery plus new bidirectional meter.On fit I get paid for everything I generate from solar but now your saying if I charge the battery from the grid that gets taken off my solar generated figure..is this correct? But not the rest of my grid use for the house? Thanks in advance.

If you have a bi-directional (net) meter, it is most usually wired to record generation used directly by the house and also any that is diverted to batteries (which you would expect as that has been generated as well).

However, if you charge the batteries from the grid, this will be seen as imported and deducted from the total reading as that part was not generated. Hence the Import, Export and Net readings.

The problem with this is that if you use significant grid charging , especially during winter months, as the battery is probably only 80-90% efficient, it will significantly reduce your Net readings during that period.

You can see from earlier posts that some have had things rewired so that the meter only shows generation direct and ignores any used by the batteries. 

Bring me Sunshine ~ E&E {Solar PV, Battery Storage, Hybrid EV, ASHP and Home Assistant automation}
Newcomer
April 27, 2025

Per the reply by from BPLightlog

The current setup you have is not 100% optimal from a FIT viewpoint. It’s not terrible by any stretch but you are definitely not maximising your payment if you have the new inverter charged on the same circuit that feeds PV to the house.

 

To get your head around it, manually read the meter and measure generation against whatever your inverter says it’s generated. The two numbers will be off, this will obviously be affected by variables such as ‘time of day’, ‘battery soc’, etc . If the battery isn’t fully drained to say 10% or whatever then the excess solar maybe hidden from the meter until it’s discharged as AC instead of stored as DC

In these sunnier months, do ensure your battery charging schedule is set to not charge AC to 100% overnight

I’ve decided to reconfigure my setup to ensure my AC charging goes via a different circuit so I can truly have the best of both worlds. Charge my batteries with cheap grid 7p AC and ensure every KW generated is shown on the bi directional meter as it used to be

 

KL

Newcomer
April 27, 2025

Thanks for your replies. Ive seen earlier comments about bidirectional meter being wired wrong. I think mine must be with regards to bplightlogs statement that charging battery would go on import. Ive had my hybrid inverter and battery with bidirectional meter around 2 weeks my exp=22.8....imp=134.8.....net= -112...do u agree this meter is wired wrong.

It seems my solar generation is on import when I think your saying it should be export,  do you agree.. thx again.